In two of the last three seasons, almost half the major college football programs didn’t publicly report a concussion
December 30, 2015 1:15PM ET Updated December 31, 2015 12:15PM ET
by Timothy Bella @TimBella
In March 2016, check out Timothy Bella’s “Life After Concussions in College Sports” panel at South by Southwest
Update (Dec. 31, 2015): Hours before the College Football Playoff, Oklahoma announced that defensive lineman Charles Walker was out due to a concussion suffered earlier in the week. The numbers below reflect the news.
Numbers define the College Football Playoff, the NCAA’s attempt at a playoff system for major college football.
Four teams. Three games. One true champion. More than $500 million in bowl revenue.
But there’s another number that’s not widely publicized, if at all: 501, the number of publicly reported concussions in major college football in the last three seasons.
The figure, which has been collected from data over the last three years, highlights a public knowledge gap in just how often concussions occur in college football. In the 2013 through 2015 seasons, each of the more than 120 schools in the NCAA Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) has publicly reported an average of four concussions — a little more than one per season.
Yet, during the 2015 season alone, there were 166 publicly reported concussions in major college football, according to the America Tonight concussion map, an annual database compiled from college football concussion data for all the FBS programs for the last three seasons. That’s an increase of about 15 percent from the 2014, but still 15 percent lower than 2013, which had 192 instances of reported head trauma in college football.
That information helps quantify a part of the much bigger story centered on concussion reporting in college athletics: The number of concussions in major college football that are publicly reported or acknowledged by coaches and athletic departments is still only a small fraction of the thousands of concussions that happen every season.
As previously reported by America Tonight, there continues to be a significant number of concussions that unfold during practices and games in major college football every season — and usually, the public doesn’t know about it.
Earlier this month, noted concussion expert Dr. Ann McKee said she’s found chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, the brain disease linked to blows to the head, in the brains of 41 of 50 former college football players she has examined.
Because of that kind of rise in awareness, at least 27 FBS players have retired from major college football due to concussions in the last three seasons. Concussion critics have needled the NCAA for having done “the worst job of any level of sports in terms of the protections they offer their players;” for every diagnosed concussion, college football players reported having 21 “dings” and six suspected concussions that, over time, can lead to more serious injuries.
With the second College Football Playoff kicking off Dec. 31, and the recent theatrical release of the film “Concussion” spurring a new round of concussion-related stories in the news, the $64,000 question is back front and center: What have we learned about concussions, and how they’re publicly reported, in college football?
Here are some of the highlights:
For the second consecutive year, more than 60 programs — nearly half the schools in major college football — didn’t publicly report a concussion.
Concussions in the FBS, 2013-2015
Create line charts
2015: 61 schools
2014: 62 schools
2013: 42 schools
During the 2015 season, 61 of 128 FBS programs, or 48 percent of schools in major college football, didn’t publicly report a concussion. This was only a slight change from the 2014 season, when 62 of 125 FBS programs didn’t publicly report a concussion.
Fifty-six percent of current top 25 teams didn’t publicly report a concussion
2014: 40 percent
2013: 44 percent
If you were a ranked team by the end of the 2015 season, you were less likely to have publicly reported a concussion than you would have been in 2013 or 2014. Fourteen programs in the final top 25 poll of the regular season didn’t publicly report a single concussion for 2015. Ranked programs included No. 1 Clemson, No. 5. Iowa, No. 6 Stanford, No. 7 Ohio State and No. 12 Ole Miss, all of which are playing in New Year’s Six bowls, college football’s most lucrative and prestigious matchups.
Fourteen percent of publicly reported concussions came from current top 25 programs
2014: 22 percent
2013: 6 percent
Ranked teams made up a sizable portion of publicly reported concussions in 2015, but that rate took a dip compared with 2014. Florida State had nine of the 23 publicly reported concussions among top 25 teams, accounting for close to 40 percent of concussions for ranked teams.
Twelve players were forced to retire because of concussions in 2015
Twelve players retired in 2015 because of one or more concussions — twice as many as the number that retired in 2013.
The 12 retired players in 2015 include:
Nick Brigham, offensive lineman, Georgia Tech
Kight Dallas, linebacker, Georgia State
Tristan Eickbush, defensive back, Wyoming
Beau Hankins, linebacker, Georgia Tech
David Henry, linebacker, Oregon State
Jared Leaf, linebacker, San Jose State
Christian Lezzer, defensive back, Boston College
AJ Long, quarterback, Syracuse
Jack Miller, offensive lineman, Michigan
Ajee Montes, defensive back, SMU
Spencer Stanley, offensive lineman, Rice
Johnny Vizcaino, offensive lineman, New Mexico
In 2015, linebackers and offensive linemen were the most likely to retire due to concussions. Offensive linemen were also one of the two most likely groups to retire due to concussion in 2014. A third of this year’s retired players hailed from the ACC. But many other previously concussed players from past years are continuing to play: 9 percent of the 335 players reporting concussions in the 2013 or 2014 seasons are currently on NFL rosters.
No man’s land: When concussions force a college football player to retire.
Casey Cochran is one of at least 27 players in college football to have retired because of concussions in recent years.
More All-Americans suffered more publicly reported concussions than any other time in the last three seasons.
Baker Mayfield, left, and Ryan Kelly are both headed to the College Football Playoff. They both have also suffered publicly reported concussions this season. Steve Nurenberg/Icon Sportswire via AP Images; Butch Dill/AP
Included in this year’s list of publicly reported concussions were four of the nation’s most decorated players. Two of the players – Oklahoma’s Baker Mayfield and Alabama’s Ryan Kelly – are playing in this year’s College Football Playoff. The other two players – Robert Nkemdiche of Ole Miss and Jourdan Lewis of Michigan – were both second-team All-America selections. In the 2013 and 2014 seasons, only two All-America selections – Florida State’s Bryan Stork and Rashad Greene – suffered publicly reported concussions.
With at least 12 publicly reported concussions, the University of Wyoming was this year’s concussion king.
2015: 12 at Wyoming
2014: 10 at Colorado
2013: 9 at Hawaii
For the third consecutive year, a team with at least 10 losses led the way, with the number of concussions going up each year for each program. This year, it was Wyoming, with a record of 2-10 and 12 publicly reported concussions. That total could actually be higher, with local media estimating the number of concussions for Wyoming to be somewhere in the 20s.
The ACC, with its 27 reported concussions, led all conferences in 2015
Concussions by FBS conferences, 2013-2015
Create bar charts
2015: 27 in the ACC
2014: 25 in Mountain West
2013: 26 in Mountain West
After two straight years of the Mountain West conference leading reported head trauma, the ACC stepped ahead, publicly reporting a dozen more concussions than it did in 2014. Among the 10 conferences and the independent programs in the FBS, the ACC also had nine of its 14 programs publicly report at least one concussion, a conference rate beat only by the Big 12.
Even with only two concussions each, Oklahoma and Houston accounted for two-thirds of publicly reported concussions among conference champions.
2015: Two at Oklahoma, two at Houston
2014: Seven at Florida State
2013: Six at Florida State
Across the board, concussion reporting among conference champions was way down in 2015, which produced just six publicly reported concussions from the 10 conference champions. In 2014, the total was 15, with Florida State leading the way. With nine concussions in 2015, the Seminoles actually recorded more concussions this year than any time in the last three years, but when Clemson won the conference, it disqualified Florida State from the category.
Aside from Oklahoma, all the programs in this year’s College Football Playoff reported no more than one concussion each.
The coaches of the four programs in this year’s College Football Playoff.Gaston De Cardenas/AP; LM Otero/AP; LM Otero/AP; Lynne Sladky/AP
Only Ohio State publicly reported having a concussion before the 2014 CFP.
It’s not looking good for the college football’s final four. For Clemson, this year’s top-ranked team, 2015 marks the second consecutive year in which the Tigers didn’t publicly report a single concussion. Their CFP comrades aren’t faring much better. It’s the third straight year Alabama has recorded just one concussion. Michigan State’s lone concussion in 2015 is actually an improvement from the two previous years of not publicly reporting a single one. And before the Sooners announced a key defensive lineman would miss the Orange Bowl with a concussion suffered earlier in the week, Oklahoma, like Alabama, had publicly reported just three concussions in the last three years.